Lerner & Lerner, P.C.

Former prosecutors with more than 50 years of combined experience

Free initial consultations ยท Phones answered 24/7
Call 516-741-4100 or
Toll Free: 800-747-4996

The insanity plea as a defense

New York residents may wonder how the insanity defense works and how common it is. Although many people who commit violent crimes are mentally ill, mental illness is not the same as insanity from a legal standpoint, and the National Institute of Mental Health found that it is used in only one out of every 100 cases in county court. Furthermore, it is only successful about 25 percent of the time.

Among the people who have used the insanity defense are John Hinckley, Jr., who attempted to shoot President Ronald Reagan, and Andrea Yates, a mother who drowned her children. However, it was unsuccessful for notorious serial killers Jeffrey Dahmer and John Wayne Gacy because it was determined that they knew the difference between right and wrong at the time of their actions. This is often the crux in determining the success of an insanity defense. A person can be mentally ill from a medical standpoint but still understand that the act that is being committed is wrong.

James Holmes, who opened fire in a Colorado movie theater in 2012, has also pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity. A favorable verdict means he will go to a mental health facility instead of facing the death penalty.

A person who is facing charges for a violent felony may wish to plead insanity if they were unable to distinguish right from wrong at the time the act occurred. One advantage of this plea is that defendants will be in a better position to receive the treatment from their mental health that they need. Depending on the charges and their progress, they may eventually be released from the mental health facility if it is determined that they no longer pose a threat to society. A criminal defense attorney can provide a further analysis to a client of the consequences of such a plea.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Email Us For A Response
  • Rated by Super Lawyers Kimberly D.Lerner Superlawyers.com
  • AV PeerReviewRated
  • Avvo badge
  • National College for DUI Defense

As seen on:

  • CNN
  • Fox News Channel
  • MSNBC

Lerner & Lerner, P.C.

Former prosecutors with more than 50 years of combined experience

Lerner & Lerner, P.C.
1 Old Country Road
Suite 125
Carle Place, NY 11514

Toll Free: 800-747-4996
Phone: 516-741-4100
Fax: 516-741-7485
Carle Place Law Office Map